-He-man have more in common with Superman and Clark Kent than any average joe in the universe. If you don't consider him as a super hero, fine, it's your opinion.
Sorry, I forgot how brutally unforgiving the internet is about using any character that isn't an absolutely perfect comparison. I picked He-Man out of a hat, but if I used someone like, I dunno, Ellen Ripley, you would have argued that she
did die in the movies, regardless of the fact she was "resurrected" later. That's why I said Ash was unique.
-Please don't pretent you know my taste by looking at my avatar. I'm not a fan of bleak endings. Good or bad ending, I just love good stories and watch many genres. That's it.
I find that you can learn a lot about a person just from their avatar, much like their handwriting. I think the problem here is that you prefer stories with a slightly darker bent than others. Which is fine, depending on the story, but in the case of Ash and the Evil Dead franchise, it's inappropriate. Ash isn't Logan, and not only because Logan doesn't have a chainsaw for a hand. Ending Logan's story on a downbeat note isn't necessarily wrong for the character, but it's VERY wrong for Ash.
-Stop executing heroes...I don't get that one. I do not work for Marvel, Hasbro and DC comics. Furthermost, I never said I want see all fictionnal characters dead. so I don't really feel concerned about this.
That comment was more directed at the vast phalanx of writers who've been influenced by the likes of George R.R. Martin and Robert Kirkman, who think it's "hip" to unexpectedly murder protagonists or otherwise good-hearted characters. It's a trend that's finally beginning to burn out.
-Continuity between Evil Dead movies is an eternal debate. I just pointed out what Sam Raimi told in interview about the character.'s fate in ED1. Yes he reformatted him in ED2 next. So yes this mean he's finally alive at the end of ED1. But that was not what he intented when he originally wrote it.
Dude, that's the entire point. Ash is an almost entirely different character in ED2 compared to how Sam Raimi wrote him in ED1. Whether Ash lived or died at the end of ED1 is completely up to you. But I feel that iconic shot when Ash was attacked by the Evil Force as the exact moment when Ash "metamorphosed" from something mortal to something immortal; not in a literal sense, but metaphorically.
-Well, If Chris Colombus had shared my opinion on Evil Dead, Kevin would have been killed at the end of the first Home Alone too. I have an opinion on Rambo, an other one for the Evil Dead franchise and so on. One do not apply to the other...
Home Alone belongs in an entirely different genre and is thus completely irrelevant to this discussion. I have no idea where you're going with that. I know it's meant to be a joke, but it kind of makes the rest of your argument look weird and confusing.
-I think you just don't got my point about Crimewave. Good to know that we're at least agree on one thing...not a very good movie.
I get your point, I just don't think it's a particularly good one IMHO.
Well, I just don't know where this is leading to...Just a reminder that we are all here for a friendly talk, I'm totally ok with the fact that you don't share the same point of view on that matter.
The thing is, ever since I first began posting here, I've noticed an odd dislike for the character of Ash. Not outright hatred, but more of a "let's get this idiot out of the way so we can REALLY make the franchise good" sort of attitude. They tried to make
Evil Dead without Ash before in the 2013 film, and it didn't take. I have no idea where they're trying to go with
Evil Dead Rise, but I don't have too much confidence. If you're about to argue that
Ash vs. Evil Dead ultimately failed even with Ash as the lead, I should point out that STARZ deliberately shoved the third season into February of 2018 so the ratings would take a dive, giving them the excuse to cancel the show. I don't know why they wanted it gone. Maybe they were just jealous of the size of Ash's boomstick.